Don't mean to sound rude but that explanation makes even less sense. I could understand to a degree if someone is used to brushed and/or less resolute textures saying the mod makes her skin look plastic due to more reflection, but proportion wise she's just the same. The mod does no shape changing whatsoever.
my comments are directly based on the alyx model. the whole reason for the updated character models was to make them look more real. however, by changing the alyx model they made it look less real. they changed a model which was purposely made to not look like the generic stereotype of a woman so many videogames have, into one that does.
sure, the "ultrarealistic" models are better than the original models, but in making these changes they also changed the core of the alyx character.
i also thought it was funny you said "stop gawking at the pics". i thought the idea behind the addon was to do just that.